原创 Figuring out why manned space exploration cost so darn much

2011-9-21 00:03 2338 16 17 分类: 消费电子

NASA recently released an estimate of how much the next phase of manned space exploration would cost, which includes a new heavy booster and capsule worth billions of dollars, see here. [There are serious doubts if this level of budget will be approved, of course.]


So I wondered: "why does manned space exploration cost so much?" and came up with these answers:


- "Costs so much" when compared to what else?


- Because it is manned, not unmanned, and a manned mission costs 10× to 100× more than an unmanned one, and take much longer to plan and engineer


- And my final answer: I don't know why.


I'm not going to second-guess the rough cost and time estimates, since I have absolutely no expertise or special insight into the project. But I am pretty sure that the estimate given has an uncertainty band of -50%/+100% (at the very least), and we know that the odds are much more likely that the error will be on the plus side rather than the minus side.


What I really wonder about is this: is it even possible to provide an answer with order-of-magnitude accuracy to the question of what it will cost, in money and time? With all the unknowns in an ambitious project like this, and all the new technologies that will have to be developed, built, tested, and assessed, you might as well spin a roulette wheel to get the answer rather than try to work it out in advance. [Look at the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to be placed at the L2 Lagrange point and which is years behind schedule and billions of dollars over initial estimates.]


Plus, there's that engineering maxim to keep in mind: we want it fast, cheap, and right—but you can only pick two of those attributes (at best).


Have you ever had projects where a tight estimate of time and cost was expected, yet you knew that any SWAG (scientific wild-ass guess) you offered was really just a WAG (SWAG without the "scientific")? Did that "soft" estimate somehow increasingly get taken and used as a real, solidÿnumber as it worked its way up the management chain, despite all the caveats or misgivings you voiced?


 

文章评论1条评论)

登录后参与讨论

用户1406868 2016-5-2 13:15

пишет:Да когда занимаешься в спорт зале нужно больше спать так как мышцы растут только во время сна и так же ÐÂÃосстанавливаютс²‘.VA:F [1.9.21_1169]Рейтинг: +2 (оценок: 2)

mqli_796119859 2011-8-15 11:59

谢谢分享 很好资源

用户1406868 2011-8-4 10:24

好东西
相关推荐阅读
用户3607565 2016-04-29 18:04
Megavolt tests expose extreme engineering challenges
With all the attention given to low-power design and products, we tend to forget that there's anot...
用户3607565 2016-03-24 11:55
Port issues: Data and power
Designers and end users now consider USB as a general-purpose, somewhat-universal charging source ...
用户3607565 2016-03-24 11:52
From metrology to existentialism
Measuring physical variables is a major challenge along two dimensions: when ever-greater precisio...
用户3607565 2016-03-19 17:33
Wall wart plus battery for small UPS: You buying?
We all know those self-contained AC/DC converters – often called “wall warts” – which power many s...
用户3607565 2016-03-14 18:39
PoE: A source for area lighting?
Do you remember the original role of the USB port? It was to replace the many diverse and incompat...
用户3607565 2016-03-14 18:36
Electric motors plus pneumatics equals awesome robotics
Robotics is hot these days, and it's certainly deserved. Today's robotic arms and systems are f...
我要评论
1
16
关闭 站长推荐上一条 /2 下一条